| |
| |
| Frequently Asked Questions about Independent
Schools |
| 1. What is
an independent school? |
|
The word independent
means that the school operates under a different mandate than a
government operated public school. An independent school is created
when a group of citizens with similar educational goals apply to
the Alberta Ministry of Education for approval to operate a school.
The school is incorporated under the provincial societies act and
receives its authority to operate from the Minister of Education.
|
| 2. Who operates
an independent school? |
|
An independent school
is governed by a board that is chosen from among the school society
membership. In most cases these people are elected by the membership.
This board is accountable to the Minister of Education and to the
membership for operating the school. Often the board creates subcommittees
to assist in maintaining the facility, overseeing finances, supervising
programs and staff, and assisting in fund-raising or organizing
other volunteer activities necessary to the operation of the school.
|
| 3. What main
aspect characterizes independent schools? |
|
As a rule parents, teachers,
and students have a high degree of commitment as a result of exercising
their right to be in an independent school. Many parents are involved
in the operation of the school.
|
| 4. What reasons
do parents have for wanting to operate a school independently? |
|
The school society and
the parents have a strong sense of ownership because they can participate
in the operation of an independent school. They have a choice and
a voice. They can ensure that teachers and curriculum stay true
to a particular mission and vision, while striving for excellence
according to provincial standards. They believe it is a natural
obligation of parents to be involved in the education of their children.
|
| 5. Why not
send their children to a public school? |
|
Many parents believe
that they have a duty to be responsible for their children's education.
Others believe that a large educational system is not responsive
to their input and can take a long time to respond to parental concern.
Some express displeasure because their children experience difficulties
within a school system. Other parents react to permissive values
or what they perceive as a lack of discipline in a school system.
Independent schools allow
children to be educated within a parentally controlled environment.
The school may have a particular academic emphasis, special needs
focus, pedagogical philosophy like Waldorf or Montessori, or faith
orientation that is compatible with the value system of the parents.
Having this grassroots governance is essential to an independent
school.
|
| 6. Do independent
schools undermine the public school system? |
|
No. They sustain and
enrich the diversity that exists among the citizens of Alberta.
By providing alternatives to mainstream education, they strengthen
democracy and multiculturalism. Independent schools are free to
be responsive to parental choice and voice.
|
| 7. Do these
schools hinder an integrated and cohesive society? |
|
Variety is part of our
multicultural Canadian and Alberta heritage. Independent schools
reflect this diversity, nurture it, and preserve particular traditions
and values. Integration, cohesion, and strengthening of the common
good can take place within diversity. Uniformity is not a prerequisite
for integration and cohesion. Given the long history of independent
schooling in Alberta it is obvious that they have not caused division.
|
| 8. Are systems
of choice good for education or do they fragment the common good? |
|
Systems of education
actually encourage choice. In the public system, magnate schools
may attract students with a particular interest like fine arts,
language, athletics, or faith affiliation. In Alberta, for example,
denying a full range of choices would mean eliminating public schools
like Nellie McClung, an all girls schools. Removing educational
choices could jeopardize the 28,000 students in French immersion
programs or the over 3000 students in Francophone schools and 125,000
students in the predominantly Catholic separate school system. The
elimination of these options would be detrimental to diversity and
would erode or undermine civil liberties. Independent schools affirm
that liberty is important in a pluralistic province. It is healthier
for government to maximize the freedom of opportunity than to stifle
it.
|
| 9. Do only
Alberta's public schools enhance democracy? |
|
This is a belief held
by some people. Those citizens who operate their own schools believe
that they too uphold and support democratic ideals. All school programs
in Alberta are expected to uphold the common good enjoyed in a democracy.
Monoculture stifles democracy while diversity enriches it. Only
a totalitarian government would erase minority interests and identities.
|
| 10. Do citizen
operated schools threaten universal access to education? |
|
So far this is not the
case. Ontario, Quebec, have a Roman Catholic school system in addition
to "common" schools. Other countries that permit a variety
of schools have not encountered this problem. Alberta has a separate
school system, a Francophone school system, charter schools, and
independent schools in addition to the public "common"
system.
|
| 11. Will
not a proliferation of schools compromise the quality of education? |
|
Not necessarily. All
schools must abide by Alberta Learning standards. Teachers must
have the required credentials and professional certificates. Studies
done on Alberta's independent schools suggest that their existence
improves the quality of schooling in general by creating an element
of competition.
|
| 12. Should
not schools avoid teaching about faith and religion? Apparently various
faith groups operate 60 % of Alberta's independent schools. |
| Alberta's
public system includes approximately 127,000 students in clearly defined
faith-based schools. These schools overtly state that their faith
allegiances are to permeate the entire atmosphere and culture of their
schools.
All schools deal in ideas
and values. They mold and shape children. Although Ministry of Learning
schools are supposedly "neutral", teachers still impart
values to students, political, moral and quasi-religious ideas.
Every textbook is a set of ideas telling what is worth learning.
Every teacher is part of the curriculum and brings ideas, values,
and experiences into the classroom. All teaching involves human
influence and imparting of various worldviews. For groups to live
together, society needs to nurture respect and toleration for diversity
and to impart compassion for one another. Pretending that faith
allegiances are not part of life would be spurious.
|
| 13. What
safeguards are there against ethnic and religious prejudice? |
|
All schools in Alberta
should encourage respect for all people as well as permit a sense
of individual and group identity. The teaching of hatred is ruled
out by "the permission to operate" and the Minister of
Education has the power to investigate any questionable teaching
practices in all schools in the province, including independent
schools.
|
| 14. How many
students are enrolled in independent schools? |
|
For the year 2009 the
number will be approximately 11,272 students and 3,000 in private
ECS centres.
|
| 15. Is enrolment
increasing? |
|
The enrolment is decreasing
as several independent schools have merged with public jurisdictions through alternative
program agreements.
|
| 16. How much
money do independent schools receive from the provincial government? |
|
Children in Early Childhood
Services (Kindergarten) receive the same funding as children in
the public systems. Children in Designated Special Education Private
Schools receive the same amount for their instruction as similar
coded children in public schools.
Children in grades 1- 9: $3,418
Grades 10 - 12: $97.66/CEU
|
| 17. How is
this money spent? |
|
The money received from
the government covers approximately 40% of the expenditure per student
in the province. The money is used for instructional costs.
|
| 18. How does
this compare to public school costs? |
|
In 1999, the average
operating cost per student in Alberta was $6207.
Capital costs were an additional $767 per student.
The provincial cost was $6,974 per student.
In 2000/2001 the cost was over $7,000.
Grade 1 - 9 independent school children received $2458.
|
| 19. What
type of expenses do independent schools incur? |
|
Instructional, support
and capital costs. Instructional costs include salaries for principal,
teachers and instructional support staff, learning resources and
supplies, and equipment and furnishings used in the instructional
program.
Support costs include plant operations and maintenance, board governance,
office administration, and student transportation.
Capital costs include building projects, building quality restoration
program expenditures and debt carrying costs on school buildings.
|
| 20. How much
does it cost to send a student to an independent school? |
|
Tuition varies significantly.
Some schools may charge an individual fee; others may have a family
rate. Current information is unavailable. Tuition is estimated at
$5,000 to $6,000 per family annually. A few school may be as low
as $2,500 per year. Other schools may charge $5,000 to $6,000 per
child. A few may charge more than $8,000 or $10,000 per child depending
on program enrichment and extracurricular activities. Boarding costs
are extra.
|
| 21. Should
not parents who send their children to an independent school pay the
full cost? |
|
The government of Alberta
repeatedly recognizes that independent schools serve the public
interest and the government believes in ensuring equal opportunity
for all children to receive an adequate education. Independent schools
are not supported equally since parents typically pay two thirds
of their children's educational costs in addition to paying their
regular school taxes. Since it is the Ministry of Education's responsibility
to ensure effective education for all children, and it is the children
and not the school that benefits, the government realizes that spending
a portion of public moneys makes good sense. Otherwise the government
would have to pay the full costs of their instruction and all additional
costs. In essence, every dollar that independent schools contribute
to education is one that the government and the taxpayers do not
pay. Millions of dollars are saved annually. When including capital
costs and differences in operating costs, the saving would average
close to $4,500 per student.
|
| 22. Do most
children who attend private schools come from wealthy families? |
|
No, more than seventy
percent are from families whose household income falls below the
national average.
|
| 23. What
type of credentials do independent schoolteachers hold? |
|
The same as public school
teachers. The Professional Development and Certification branch
approves the teaching certificates in independent schools as well
as public.
|
| 24. Who inspects
independent schools? |
|
Ministry of Education
has a monitoring program that requires audits, annual reports and
three year plans, verification of all teaching credentials, and
on site visits. The schools are required to meet the same program
goals as the public system and the student performance is tested
just like it is in the public schools.
|
| 25. Who determines
the curriculum at an independent school and how is its effectiveness
measured? |
|
The school authority,
the teachers and the local authority develop a curriculum that meets
the Goals of the Alberta Program of studies. Ministry of Education
ensures that the programs are compatible. And the outcomes are tested
by the grade 3, 6, and 9 provincial achievement tests and the grade
12 provincial exams to ensure that the curriculum and the graduates
meet the standards.
|
| 26. Do special
needs students attend independent schools? Are there resources for
them? |
| Yes. Most
independent schools accommodate general special needs students and
high needs students to the degree that they have resources and programs
available. They receive 40% less funding for general special needs
children so it is understandable that they are not always able to
meet the needs of every child.
There are seventeen independent
schools devoted to educating special needs students. These schools
are known as Designated Special Education Private Schools (DSEPS).
They serve many of the mild to moderate and severe needs children.
The parents of these children believe that their child's needs are
better met in these specialized environments. Often parents and
children are referred to these schools by public boards.
|